Alright. I figured this point would be brought up the instant it was suggested to me that a 'Shop' was going to become a part of the site at some point post-launch. Before you all jump on the 'Boycott MBP' and 'You're Breaking the EULA' bandwagon, allow me to clarify the vague 'Shop' feature that's in the works (as best as I understand - I am not part of the Shop development team):
Let me first make it very clear that You are not expected NOR required to donate any amount of money in order to download, install, and play the game with other players.. Please note the usage of the word donation. We are not demanding that any user at any point in time must pay us for usage of the modification to the game, which falls in perfect sync with the original terms of agreement lined up in the original OK from the shareholders when the mod was initially conceived so many years ago.
With this in mind, we are obviously aware of the challenges this poses to walking the line of borderline illicit activity. There has been much discussion amongst the development teams to ensure we are not breaking our current agreement to ensure both parties are satisfied, while at the same time providing a convenient way for both users and staff to enjoy the game and maintain our web services.
Now let's take a look at the 'Shop' feature. While I cannot speak on behalf of MBP, since I am not associated with the MBP development process, I can provide a full disclosure of any items that MAY be featured in the 'Shop' that reflect MBF:
- Users will be able to purchase a CUSTOM MULTIPLAYER SKIN PACK, including several reskinned versions of the MBF marble for usage in MBP Multiplayer Games. This is purely aesthetic and provides no advantage over other players whatsoever. If we want to get technical, I designed the skins, and therefore I technically own the rights to distribute my artwork.
At this point, nothing beyond the extent of the MBFubar skins will be available in the online store. MBFubar will continue to be a standalone singleplayer client with no multiplayer capabilities aside from the ability to chat with users on Webchat and MBP Leaderboards / MBP Multiplayer, and it will be freely available and distributed without the original core engine files to ensure it conforms with any agreements.
As far as MBP goes, the only items that I am aware of at this time that will be offered in the in-game store is a series of marble skin bundles that are unlockable for MBP multiplayer. As far as I know, these items are also purely AESTHETIC and provide no statistical advantage over other players (aside from bragging rights).
Let's look back at the general topic here; the shop will be fueled by DONATIONS. We are not asking users to hand us money hand-over-fist, and we are certainly not attempting to give users a certain advantage over other players that may choose to not help support the site. The idea behind the shop is to reward donators with exclusive and unique flags in a couple of databases to allow them to stand out from other users. This is already evident by the unique donation achievements that can be seen on the user profile on the website.
The sole idea behind the donation-funded shop is to reward users who donate 'x' dollars at some point in time with a simple flat credit number that they can then use to buy special aesthetic upgrades for their Multiplayer gameplay experience, and an additional small amount of credits added to their account each month to show our appreciation for their contributions to helping keep our website, multiplayer, and our community alive.
I lastly would like to make it very clear that I do not support pay-to-win models, and I do not typically donate my money to third party sites for cosmetic upgrades. I spent a lot of time discussing with the development teams to ensure the 'Shop' feature you are hearing about provides no advantages to any users and that we do not overstep our boundaries with the original terms of service. I'm also making it clear that I am not involved in the development process and currently have no knowledge about its contents other than the database flags that I may implement for Marble Blast Fubar. Finally, I want to ensure everyone understands that this is a donation system that rewards donators with unique database flags, and in no way is an attempt to re-sell Marble Blast content to users. I think you'll find that all of MBP's content is available to all users regardless of their donation status, and the same goes for MBF (when released).
To touch on the issue of where the donations go, all donations are currently fueling a custom PayPal account built specifically for this site, and its resources are currently used to pay for this website's hosting fees directly. The only user with access into that account is IsraeliRD himself, and the rest of us aren't even able to see what numbers are coming out of it.
Promarbler and Jeff have both brought up some critical and integral points in this discussion, and I openly encourage others to express your comments or concerns on the subject so that we may better serve you - the community. I certainly hope you do not see this as a purchase of additional content, since the only 'content' we plan to provide is aesthetic and gives players no in-game advantages whatsoever. The true idea behind the Shop is to give users a choice of fun items and skins to choose from for helping the community stay running.
Would it help to rename this feature the 'Rewards' or 'Donator Perks' section?
I will closely monitor this thread and provide feedback as best as I can, though my time online is limited these days.
Thanks,
~Aayrl